Experimental Assessment of Toughness in Ceramic Matrix Composites using the J-integral with Digital Image Correlation Part II: Application to Ceramic Matrix Composites

This paper is the second of a two-part series assessing the feasibility of using the J-integral with full-field deformation data from Digital Image Correlation (DIC) to characterize toughness in continuous fiber, SiCf/SiCc ceramic matrix composites (CMCs). In Part I, line and area integral adaptations of the J-integral were validated with analytical and experimental deformation fields. It was found that variability in experimental data and contour truncation at the crack wake introduced error and path-dependency, but this could be mitigated through data filtering. In this paper, the line and area integral methods were evaluated for cross-ply and longitudinal CMC tensile specimens. It is demonstrated that these approaches cannot be used for quantitative characterization, but can be successfully used to examine qualitative trends. For both architectures, area integral measurements of the potential energy release rate, J, were larger (and arguably more accurate) than line integral measurements. Resistance curves were characteristic of tough materials, but the stress intensity magnitudes were larger in the longitudinal laminates than the cross-ply (for equivalent crack extension). Experimentally derived bridging laws showed that fiber bridging tractions were largest in the cross-ply laminates, which was attributed to a lower volume fraction of longitudinal fibers. Quantitative, single-value measurements of fracture toughness could not be established since: (1) noise in the DIC data masked strain signals indicative of first matrix cracking, and (2) widespread matrix cracking rendered the J-integral invalid (regardless of size and position, the boundaries of the line and area contours inevitably intercepted microcracks). Rather, gross estimates of toughness and stress intensity factors were made under the assumption that the limitations in the spatial resolution of the DIC data essentially transforms regions with fine microracking along the contour into continuous regions of elastic deformation. When evaluated with the J-integral, the smoothed deformation fields manifest as resistance curves indicative of a tough material. Thus, the J-integral was valuable for qualitative assessments of toughening mechanisms in the CMCs.